Friday, January 30, 2009

Level 3 "snow emergency"

"Level 3 Snow Emergency: All roadways are closed to non-emergency personnel. No one else should be out during these conditions unless it is absolutely necessary to travel. All employees should contact their employers to see if they should report to work. Those traveling on the roadways may be subject to arrest."

Some thoughts on this:


  • There is no consistency between the levels in the different counties. Meigs (where men are still men) had no declared "emergency", though it neighbors Athens county which had a level 3, how could that be?
  • Athens county has a history of inflating this "snow emergency" level in the past. Once we were in a store in Athens and they started telling us we needed to leave because we were under a level 3 emergency. It hadn't even started snowing yet! So, our new Sheriff is an improvement in this regard. He actually waited until we had winter conditions in ...um...winter. I had a fellow at work tell me yesterday that Athens county is really bad. I asked him how he knew that and he said he heard it on the news that we were under a "level 3". I explained that every time it snows more than 2 inches we are under a level 3 and the news doesn't really understand the history. But since it's on the "news" it must be true. Kirk Greenfield (WTAP's Meteorologist) has taken great umbrage at my comments on WTAP.com about the "snow emergency" inflation in Athens County. His assumption was since Athens County was under a level 3, it must have been a lot worse than other local counties. This is the wrong assumption due to the above comments.
  • The County Engineer would always prefer that we don't drive on the roads anytime it snows. The Sheriff needs to take this into account when he makes his decision under pressure from the Engineers office. (Come to think of it, if they could keep those pesky vehicles off the roads all year long, we'd never have a pot-hole problem.)
  • There have been times where locals (driving "illegally" in a "level 3") have cut trees out of the road so the county's snow plows can make it through. I also know of an instance where "illegal" drivers pulled a Township truck from being stuck over a snow covered bank.
  • We are the ones that have to attend to elderly neighbors who have no power. Generators run on gasoline. Gasoline is sold a various locations. One has to drive to get there.
  • One has to drive to cut the trees off of parent's houses.
  • One has to drive to take a load of firewood to neighbors who now have no electric, hence no heat.

Have we even thought about the consequences if people actually listened to the Sheriff (it's the county engineer that prods this decision, by the way) when he "declares" a "snow emergency"?

  • Most commerce in southeastern Ohio would cease. We have rt 7, 50 and 33 all major highways running through Athens county. If we all followed the "rules" every semi truck (along with every car/truck heading from / to work) would stop at the county lines. How much snow removal would be happening around traffic jams.
  • If we all followed the "rules" local elderly people would have died from the cold. We haven't seen the county trucks delivering firewood or meals on wheels delivering meals. Neighbors should be allowed (and if not allowed, do it anyway) to help their neighbors.
  • If we followed the rules we'd have people working 24-36 hours because no one comes to work to relieve them.
  • In this slow economy we are going to tell people not to go to work unless it's necessary? We don't get paid unless we go to work. Work is necessary from an economic point of view no matter what.

So, while the government and the media try to make us into whimpering, thumb sucking in the corner adolescents........some of us ignore the rules and act like men.

If we followed the "rules" we'd have a real snow emergency.

I've got an idea for Kirk Greenfield. Instead of giving the population the impression that Athens county is a lot worse off than all the neighboring counties, maybe he should ask why that all winter storms are worse in Athens county, because their "snow emergency" levels are always higher than our neighbors in bordering counties....you'd think studying this phenomenon would be a meteorologist's dream.

Got to go now, have to refill the generator, put wood in the stove. I haven't seen the government here offering to do that for me, yet.

We've turned into a nation of wimps.

3 comments:

  1. If you would read the ORC you will discover that if you are driving on City Streets or State Routs the Levels placed by the County Sheriff do not apply. They are only enforceable on County and Township Roads.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thanks for the comment Roger.

    However, after reading the so called applicable sections of the orc, 311.07 and 311.08 one cannot find anything explicit about a "snow emergency" There is an Attorney General's oppinion # 97-015 that declares that County Sheriff's can impose a snow "emergency" using 311.07 and 311.08 as a basis. Even though it's a real stretch. Sort of like the US Supreme Court finding a right to an abortion in the US Constitution. According to this opinion #97-015, the Sheriff has the right to impose the same restrictions on federal, state, municipal, county and township roadways.
    "1997 Op. Att’y Gen. No. 97-015 (a county sheriff may, pursuant to R.C. 311.07 and R.C. 311.08, declare a snowemergency and temporarily close state roads and municipal streets within his jurisdiction when such action is reasonably necessary for the preservation of the public peace"

    http://74.125.95.132/search?q=cache:uO7KAjcjuf8J:www.ag.state.oh.us/legal/opinions/2007/2007-029.pdf+Ohio+Attorney+General%27s+Opinion+97-015&hl=en&ct=clnk&cd=2&gl=us

    "The Sheriff may, pursuant to Ohio Revised Code Sections 311.07 and 311.08, declare a snow emergency and temporarily close all or certain highways, roads and streets within his jurisdiction when such action is reasonably necessary for the preservation of the public peace. Ohio Attorney Generals Opinion 97-015 issued April 1, 1997, concludes that this authority includes all Federal and State highways, County and Township roads and Municipal streets. Any person who knowingly hampers or fails to obey a lawful order of the Sheriff declaring a snow emergency and temporary closing highways, roads and/or streets within his jurisdiction, may be subject to criminal prosecution under Ohio Revised Code Section 2917.13, Misconduct at an Emergency."
    http://www.weathersafety.ohio.gov/SnowEmergencyClassifications2007.aspx

    ReplyDelete
  3. Like violating concealed carry laws,d I believe some say it is better to be judged by 12 than carried by 6. Same applies for violation of snow emergency laws. As a non-wimp, I advocate same rationale in disobeying snow levels. The death business was conducted during a level and no one was even sliding. My niece was killed Tusday AM on Baker Road. Her mson was driving and she was sitting in the back seat of the car where seat belts are not mandated. Guess what? It was drinking and speed, but charged to icy road conditions. No sobriety tests administered to driver who just killed his mother.

    Evidently the Sheriff or Highway Patrol had to clear the accident scene quickly in order to find snow level violators. You are right on Loydho. You are more likely to be injured encountering a drunken driver than you are to be injured on snow emergency roads, but less likely to be arrested for alcohol abuse if you kill someone on icy roads while drinking. This is Athens County.

    ReplyDelete

Blog Archive